Finding the perfect eyeliner that delivers smooth application, bold color, and lasting wear can feel like a challenge. Enter the MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner—a product that promises to bring definition and warmth to your eyes without the sharpness of traditional black liners. Whether you’re after a natural, everyday vibe or a smokey, sultry look for a night out, this eyeliner has gained a loyal following. But does it truly live up to its reputation? Let’s explore everything you need to know about this much-talked-about product, and see if it’s worth adding to your makeup bag.

MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner

The MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner is part of MAC’s well-known Eye Kohl collection. Its defining feature is a rich, warm brown shade with a slight red undertone, which makes it a fantastic alternative to the harshness of black. It’s perfect for anyone wanting to define their eyes without overdoing it, and the color works beautifully on various skin tones.

Designed to be soft enough for blending but pigmented enough for boldness, it’s the ideal pencil for achieving soft smokey eyes or everyday eye definition. Whether you’re a makeup newbie or an expert, this eyeliner is easy to work with and fits effortlessly into any routine.

Ingredients

What makes MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner special is its thoughtfully crafted formula. As with all MAC products, it’s dermatologist-tested and gentle enough for those with sensitive eyes. Here are the key ingredients:

• Wax-based blend: This ensures that the pencil glides smoothly and doesn’t tug at your skin.
• Jojoba oil: Keeps the liner creamy and hydrates the skin.
• Vitamin E: Not only does it nourish, but it also helps the eyeliner stay in place longer.

This combination makes for a smooth, creamy application that lasts.

Packaging and Design

Like most MAC products, the Costa Riche Eyeliner is packaged in MAC’s signature sleek, black pencil design. It’s sturdy, and the sharpenable tip means you can always keep it precise, which is perfect for creating both thin lines and bold, smokey looks. The design feels sophisticated and is a perfect fit for any makeup collection.

Texture and Scent

This eyeliner strikes a great balance with its texture—creamy enough to glide effortlessly, yet firm enough that it doesn’t crumble. It’s incredibly smooth, allowing you to apply it without any pulling or irritation.

A major plus? There’s no strong scent. While some eyeliners carry a noticeable odor, Costa Riche is completely neutral, making it great for those sensitive to smells.

Application and Usage

Applying the MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner is a breeze. The creamy consistency means it’s easy to apply in one smooth motion, whether on your lash line or waterline.

For a softer, natural look, a single swipe on the upper lash line gives a gentle definition. Want something bolder? Layer it on or use a blending brush to smudge it out for a smokier look. Since it sets nicely, you won’t have to worry about it fading or smudging throughout the day.

Results

After using MAC Costa Riche, your eyes will be beautifully defined with a warm, soft brown hue. It enhances your eyes without looking too stark and lasts throughout the day, even in humid conditions. Once it sets, it’s resistant to transferring, which is perfect for all-day wear. Whether you’re going for subtle or dramatic, this eyeliner delivers consistent, flattering results.

My Experience

For me, the MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner has become an essential part of my makeup routine. I love how it enhances my eyes with a warm, soft look that never feels too intense. It’s my go-to for days when I want something more gentle than black liner, yet still want my eyes to stand out.

One of my favorite things about it is how long it lasts. I never have to worry about it smudging or fading throughout the day, even in warm weather. It’s become one of those products I reach for again and again, and I can’t imagine my routine without it.

Similar Products

If you’re looking to compare or find similar eyeliners, here are a few options:

• Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Whiskey: Known for its creamy formula and staying power.
• Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl in Barbarella Brown: A similar rich brown pencil that’s easy to blend.
• NARS High-Pigment Longwear Eyeliner in Mambo: Offers a comparable warm brown shade with excellent color payoff.

Pros

• Smooth, creamy texture for easy application.
• Long-lasting and resists smudging.
• Warm brown shade softens the eyes without being too bold.
• Blends effortlessly for a smokey look.
• Gentle enough for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Cons

• You need to sharpen it, which can be a downside if you prefer twist-up pencils.
• It’s slightly more expensive than drugstore alternatives.
• For very oily eyelids, it may need a bit of setting powder to prevent minor transfer.

Frequently Asked Questions About MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner

1. What color is MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner?

MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner features a warm, rich brown shade with subtle red undertones. This gives it a softer, more natural appearance compared to black eyeliner, making it an excellent choice for daytime looks or anyone looking to define their eyes without harsh lines.

2. Is MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner long-lasting?

Absolutely! This eyeliner is known for its long-wearing formula, which stays put for hours without fading or smudging—perfect for all-day wear. If you have oily eyelids, a little setting powder can help it last even longer.

3. Can I use MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner on my waterline?

Yes, you can! The creamy formula is gentle enough for the waterline and applies smoothly. It’s comfortable for those with sensitive eyes, so it works well for both the lash line and waterline.

4. Is MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner safe for sensitive eyes?

Definitely! This eyeliner is dermatologist-tested and safe for sensitive eyes. It’s also suitable for contact lens wearers, so you can use it with peace of mind.

5. How do I sharpen the MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner?

Costa Riche is a traditional pencil that requires sharpening. You can use any standard eyeliner sharpener, which helps maintain a precise tip for accurate application every time.

6. How does MAC Costa Riche compare to black eyeliner?

While black eyeliner creates a bold, dramatic effect, Costa Riche offers a softer, more natural look. Its warm brown hue defines the eyes without being overly intense, making it perfect for everyday wear or a subtle smoky eye.

7. Is the texture of MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner creamy or dry?

The eyeliner has a creamy, smooth texture that glides on easily without tugging on the skin. It’s effortless to apply and can be smudged for a smoky effect before it sets.

8. Does MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner work for smoky eye looks?

Yes, indeed! Its creamy formula and blendable texture make Costa Riche perfect for creating smoky eyes. You can smudge it out for a softer effect or layer it on for more drama, making it versatile for both natural and bold styles.

9. Does it have any scent?

No, the Eyeliner is completely fragrance-free, which is great for anyone sensitive to scents.

10. What other eyeliners are similar to MAC Costa Riche?

If you’re looking for similar rich brown tones, consider these alternatives:

• Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Whiskey
• Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl in Barbarella Brown
• NARS High-Pigment Longwear Eyeliner in Mambo

These options offer a creamy texture and lasting wear, just like Costa Riche.

11. Does MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner smudge easily?

Once it sets, MAC Costa Riche holds up well against smudging. However, if you want a smoky look, be sure to blend it before it dries. For those with oily skin, using a setting powder can help prevent any smudging.

12. How much does MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner cost?

The price of MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner is generally higher than drugstore brands but is considered reasonable for a premium product.

Conclusion

All in all, the MAC Costa Riche Eyeliner is a standout product that’s worth trying if you’re looking for a versatile, high-quality liner. Its smooth texture, flattering shade, and long-lasting formula make it a great option for anyone who wants their eyeliner to work as hard as they do. Whether you’re going for a soft, everyday look or something more intense, Costa Riche has the versatility and performance to fit right into your routine. If you’re in the market for a warm, brown liner that enhances your eyes without overwhelming them, this might just be your new