Best Eyeliner Pencils

Eyeliner pencils are a favorite among makeup lovers because they offer versatility, ease of use, and long-lasting color without the mess that comes with liquid liners. The right pencil can quickly define, enhance, or completely transform your eyes. In this guide, we’ll look at some of the best eyeliner pencils available, highlighting options that cater to various styles, preferences, and skin types.

1. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Why We Love It: This pencil is a cult favorite for a reason! It applies smoothly and delivers impressive color payoff, gliding effortlessly along your lash line. It’s a hit with both beginners and pros.
Best For: Long-lasting wear (up to 16 hours) and water resistance.
Shades: Over 30 shades to choose from, ranging from classic black and brown to fun purples and metallic greens.
Tips: For a smoky eye, this creamy formula is fantastic for smudging right after application.

2. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick

Why We Love It: If you’re looking for an affordable option that doesn’t skimp on quality, this is it! The Epic Wear Liner Stick is highly pigmented and stays put all day without smudging.
Best For: Budget-friendly bold colors; it’s great for tightlining due to its creamy texture.
Shades: A wide selection, including nudes, neutrals, and vibrant hues.
Tips: Try bold shades like turquoise or deep purple on your lower lash line for something different!

3. Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon

Why We Love It: This is a fantastic hybrid between a gel and a crayon, making it super smooth to apply. It’s also one of the most long-lasting eyeliners you’ll find.
Best For: Using on the waterline and achieving smudge-proof looks; perfect for hot weather or long events.
Shades: Features both classic and unique shades, some with shimmery finishes.
Tips: Apply with a light hand since the gel formula is highly pigmented and glides on easily.

4. Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eyeliner Pencil

Why We Love It: This pencil combines the staying power of a liquid liner with the simplicity of a pencil. It’s perfect for sultry, smudged looks.
Best For: Smoky eyes and all-day wear with a soft finish.
Shades: Essential colors like black and brown, plus eye-enhancing shades like midnight blue.
Tips: Pair it with smoky eyeshadow for a dramatic evening look.

5. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Why We Love It: This eyeliner is smudge-proof and waterproof, making it ideal for anyone who needs a liner that can handle tears, sweat, or splashes of water. It’s creamy but sets quickly.
Best For: Tightlining, waterline use, and all-day wear without needing touch-ups.
Shades: Comes in both matte and shimmer options to suit various styles.
Tips: Use it for beach or pool days when you need something that won’t budge.

6. L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner

Why We Love It: This drugstore gem offers intense pigmentation and a waterproof formula that can compete with high-end products. You get luxury quality without breaking the bank!
Best For: High-performance at an affordable price, especially in humid or wet conditions.
Shades: Classic shades like black, brown, and navy.
Tips: The creamy formula is blendable, making it great for smoky eyes if you use a brush to blend it out.

7. Sephora Collection Contour Eye Pencil 12hr Wear Waterproof

Why We Love It: This pencil delivers a high-quality, waterproof formula at a great price. It applies smoothly and has vibrant color, making it perfect for both beginners and makeup pros.
Best For: Budget-friendly all-day wear and bold colors.
Shades: A wide variety, including bright colors and metallics.
Tips: Try out metallic shades on your lower lash line to really make your eyes pop.

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner Pencil for You

Here are a few tips to help you find your perfect eyeliner pencil:

• Formula Preference: If you like softer, smoky looks, go for a pencil that blends easily, like a kohl or creamy formula. For sharper, defined lines, stick with gel or waterproof pencils.
• Wear Time: Waterproof formulas are a must if you’re in humid or wet environments, while long-wear pencils are great for events and long days out.
• Color Choices: Black and brown are classic, but don’t hesitate to explore metallics and bright colors to spice up your eye looks.
• Skin Sensitivity: If you have sensitive eyes or wear contacts, look for hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested formulas.

Frequently Asked Questions on Best Eyeliner Pencils

1. What types of eyeliner pencils are there?

• Kohl Pencils: These are super soft and creamy, great for creating a smoky look.
• Gel Pencils: They’re usually long-lasting and don’t smudge easily, plus they glide on really well.
• Liquid Pencils: These offer bold color and precision, perfect for more dramatic styles.
• Retractable vs. Sharpenable: Retractable pencils are handy and mess-free, while sharpenable ones let you create a finer tip.

2. How do I pick the right eyeliner pencil?

• Think about your eye type (like if they’re sensitive or oily) and the look you’re going for (natural, bold, or smoky).
• If your eyes are sensitive, opt for hypoallergenic options.
• Consider the formula: gel and liquid pencils usually last longer.

3. What’s the best way to apply eyeliner pencil?

• Start with clean, dry eyelids.
• For a natural look, line your lashes, beginning from the inner corner.
• To go bolder, build up the color and use a smudging tool or brush for a smoky vibe.
• Setting it with a bit of eyeshadow can help it last longer.

4. Which brands are popular for eyeliner pencils?

• Urban Decay: Known for their bright colors and long-lasting wear.
• NARS: Offers a great range of shades and finishes.
• Maybelline: Affordable and reliable options.
• Charlotte Tilbury: Luxurious formulas that glide on smoothly.
• Stila: Well-known for waterproof liquid pencils.

5. Are there eyeliner pencils for sensitive eyes?

• Absolutely! Look for brands that specifically say they’re hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested, like Clinique, Almay, and Tarte.

6. How do I remove eyeliner pencil?

• Use a gentle eye makeup remover or micellar water. Just soak a cotton pad and hold it against your closed eye for a moment before wiping it away.

7. Can I use eyeliner pencil on my waterline?

• Many eyeliners are safe for that, but make sure to check the label to avoid any irritation.

8. How can I make my eyeliner pencil last longer?

• Prime your eyelids with an eyeshadow primer first.
• You can also set the pencil with a matching eyeshadow.
• Try to avoid touching your eyes to keep it from smudging.

9. Any tips for beginners using eyeliner pencils?

• Start with short, light strokes instead of trying to draw a whole line at once.
• Experiment with different techniques, like tightlining or winged eyeliner.
• Don’t stress about making it perfect; you can always smudge or fix mistakes with a cotton swab.

10. How should I store my eyeliner pencils?

• Keep them in a cool, dry spot away from direct sunlight to help preserve their formula.
• Make sure to sharpen them regularly to keep the tip nice and precise.

Conclusion

Eyeliner pencils are a must-have in any makeup collection. The best choice for you depends on your lifestyle, budget, and personal style. From budget-friendly staples to luxurious options, each of these picks offers a unique application experience. And remember, don’t be afraid to experiment—mix and match colors, techniques, and formulas to discover your signature eyeliner look!